You are here: Home / Community Assets Search / Ad Hoc Workgroup - A path forward for exploring collective impact opportunities

Ad Hoc Workgroup - A path forward for exploring collective impact opportunities

openBEAM.net August 09, 2016 Report On Byron Public Schools

Contents

Introduction 

openBEAM.net received the following informaton from one of the agencies that attended the August 2 Ad Hoc Committee meeting.

My opinion

My understanding is that the following information has been reviewed by meeting participants and is open to the public. Its purpose seems to be to clarify the purpose of the "ad hoc" committee and to allay some of the concerns expressed on social media and the public media about the ad hoc committee. 

Though not its detail, I myself have known superficially about the effort of attempting to encourage more collaboration among public/private (ie: government, social, commerce) sectors from the Facebook Coffee with Local Leaders bi-weekly meetings.

I also believe we need more collaboration and less competition. And having an "ad hoc committee" is a small and informal attempt toward encouraging dialog and collaboration.

Seeing now the reaction such well intentioned effort could stir, I will suggest that such community effort in order to gain trust and legitimacy and have traction should adopt a more formal structure and process.

What we need is a systems approach to collaboration. And the Collective Impact model is as good as any. According to Wikipedia, the CI model requires the following 5 elements:

  • Common Agenda: All participating organizations (government agencies, non-profits, community members, etc.) have a shared vision for social change that includes a common understanding of the problem and a joint approach to solving the problem through agreed upon actions.
  • Shared Measurement System: Agreement on the ways success will be measured and reported with a short list of key indicators across all participating organizations.
  • Mutually Reinforcing Activities: Engagement of a diverse set of stakeholders, typically across sectors, coordinating a set of differentiated activities through a mutually reinforcing plan of action.
  • Continuous Communication: Frequent communications over a long period of time among key players within and across organizations, to build trust and inform ongoing learning and adaptation of strategy.
  • Backbone Organization: Ongoing support provided by an independent staff dedicated to the initiative. The backbone staff tends to play six roles to move the initiative forward:[1] Guide Vision and Strategy; Support Aligned Activity; Establish Shared Measurement Practices; Build Public Will; Advance Policy; and Mobilize Funding.[6]

 

April Suitor had presented the Collective Impact model in March 2013 to CNG.

Given the scope of change that is occurring in our community and the lack of trust that exists, the time is ripe for a leader to step up to sponsor a systems approach to enable collaboration.

 

 

Ad Hoc Committee "Press Release"

2016-08-09 Shiela Kiscaden public message


 

Ad Hoc Committee 8/2/2016 Meeting Agenda

As reported by one of the agencies that attended the meeting


 

Comments

.


openBEAM.net August 09, 2016 Report On Byron Public Schools

Admin Info

TOC:

File:

DMC Impact(s): Livable City UMR and Recreation

PlanScape(s): Best Practice ; Business Process ; Civic Engagement ; Recreation & Open Space ; Vision/Identity

Community Health Impact(s):

Date: 2016/08/09

Source: openBEAM.net

Type: Status

Sort Order: 1

State: Public

.

Site Information
Project Phase Definitions
The following defines the various project phases:
  1. Available - a product, program or service is in production
  2. Develop - program or application is being developed
  3. Plan - idea is solid, stakeholders are identified, and there is strong commitment to go forward from all parties.
  4. Concept Phase - idea scoped out with enough details to give an early sizing and/or to build a proof of concept
    demonstration
  5. Pre-concept Phase - an early idea or a requirement.
About Beam
  • For the commercial sector, we tend to register startup activities (new companies and new commercial projects) that bring diversification and high-impact opportunities to the area.
  • For the non-profit sector, we wish to shine light on all the organizations and services that otherwise labor under relative obscurity.
  • Our hope is that dmcbeam.org will encourage cross-sector collaborations and creative solutions.

While there are a number of registries in the community, dmcbeam.org's  distinct value is to pilot a database with a data structure and categorizations that answer the questions such as: What organizations or projects/programs in our community that have purported relevance with some of the over-arching focuses put forward by initiatives such as DMC, J2G and Health Improvements?

This database could be used as one of the ways to explore the capacities of the community. If you are someone on an exploratory journey to learn about the greater Rochester community. dmcbeam.org could be an interesting first step.

Links to Beam sub-sites 
Sample of Beam sub-sites: